I have not tried Neutrogena skinID, though i've kinda been wanting to.
i've tried numerous products (AcneFree, Clearasil Ultra, and Clean and Clear Advantage) but none have worked as well as the one I'm using now, which is the Neutrogena Stress Control Power Cream Wash. I was hesitant to buy it because I was scared it would be too moisturizing and would end up just making my skin oily. Turns out, it works amazingly well. It's feels really smooth and creamy when I apply it to my face and afterwards my skin feels so soft and looks refreshed and glowy, and it helps get rid of new breakouts like right away. I use it with the Stress Control Triple Action Toner. The stress control line has soothers in them like aloe and cucumber that really help with the tone and feel of my skin...I highly recommend it, I have the exact same skin as you. I hope it works if you decide to try it!